BBC One broadcast the first live show of Strictly Come Dancing series 24 with a new presenting trio comprising Emma Willis, Josh Widdicombe, and Johannes Radebe following the departure of longtime hosts Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman. The significant shake-up to the flagship ballroom competition generated immediate criticism from viewers regarding the broadcasting abilities and timing errors of the newly appointed hosts during the live transmission.
While veteran presenter Emma Willis received acclaim for her hosting performance, comedian Josh Widdicombe faced heavy online backlash for visibly missing cues, looking awkward, and hesitating onstage during live handovers. Viewers on social media platforms like X expressed concern over the new three-person structure, with some labeling the comedian a “spare part” next to the experienced Willis.
Addressing the Backlash and Technical Stumbles
During the live broadcast, Widdicombe struggled with timing on the dance floor. After Johannes Radebe asked who was dancing next, Widdicombe remained silent for several seconds, causing an awkward pause before Emma Willis stepped in. The same timing problem occurred again later in the show, fueling criticism about the trio’s chemistry and pacing.
Addressing the online reaction during an episode of his podcast Parenting Hell alongside co-host Rob Beckett, Widdicombe revealed his strategy for handling the incoming critical commentary. “I pulled the drawbridge up in 2008 when I started standup,” said Josh Widdicombe. The comedian explained that he relies on a phone app blocking device called Brick to restrict access to distracting smartphone applications and limit his daily social media consumption.
Co-host Emma Willis also appeared to address the atmosphere surrounding the show by sharing behind-the-scenes snaps on Instagram. The final image featured a pink canvas with the message: “You will get judged either way, so may as well pick the fun option.” Despite the initial online critique, Willis had previously expressed enthusiasm for her debut, writing that she had “never had so much fun.”
Industry Reactions and Expert Commentary
The new format has sparked wider debate within the television industry regarding how duties are divided. Broadcaster Richard Osman weighed in on his podcast The Rest Is Entertainment, suggesting that Widdicombe might be better suited to the auditorium role currently handled by Johannes Radebe, while noting that the production team may need time to establish a format that highlights Radebe’s background as a professional dancer.
Meanwhile, judge Motsi Mabuse defended the presenters on social media, cautioning against online users “tearing apart real human beings on television.” Despite the hosting turbulence, the competition on the dance floor proceeded strongly, with John Nellis and Katya Jones topping the leaderboard with 31 points for their Foxtrot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who are the new hosts of Strictly Come Dancing for series 24?
The new presenting trio consists of Emma Willis, comedian Josh Widdicombe, and professional dancer Johannes Radebe.
Who did the new hosts replace?
They replaced long-standing presenters Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman, who stepped down at the conclusion of the 2025 series.
What specific issues did viewers have with Josh Widdicombe?
Viewers criticized Widdicombe for missing cues, hesitating during live handovers, and experiencing timing delays during the first live broadcast.
How did Josh Widdicombe respond to the online criticism?
Widdicombe explained on his podcast Parenting Hell that he completely avoids looking at critical commentary by using a smartphone app blocker called Brick to limit his social media consumption.
Did other industry figures comment on the new presenting setup?
Yes, figures like Richard Osman discussed the division of hosting duties on his podcast, and judge Motsi Mabuse posted online defending the presenters against harsh public criticism.
