Maria Avila, the former housekeeper who was severely mauled by a guard dog at Chris Brown’s Tarzana home, has agreed to accept a reduced damages award of $9.5 million. This choice avoids a new trial. The legal resolution comes months after a Los Angeles jury initially awarded Avila $12.9 million following a two-week trial regarding the December 2020 attack.
Due to high traffic on this story, please verify you are not a bot to instantly unlock the remaining content. Takes only 5 seconds!
Verify & Continue ReadingLos Angeles County Superior Court Judge Huey P. Cotton previously deemed the original jury verdict excessive. In a conditional order, the judge stated that trial evidence did not support extensive permanent nerve damage claims. He also questioned the allocation for future pain and suffering. Judge Cotton gave Avila the choice of consenting to a reduced award of $9.5 million or undergoing a new trial focused strictly on damages.
Avila’s attorney, Nancy Doumanian, filed a formal notice of acceptance in court. The legal filing confirmed that Avila consented to the downward adjustment of her damages award. This followed the court’s September 29 order. By accepting the reduction, Avila secures a substantial payout while avoiding the legal expenses, emotional distress, and unpredictability of a new trial.
The revised $9.5 million judgment is structured to include $3.85 million for past non-economic losses, $5.4 million for future non-economic losses, and $250,000 earmarked for future medical care. Meanwhile, a separate $885,000 verdict awarded to Avila’s sister, Patricia-who also worked at the property and rushed to help during the attack-remains entirely intact.
Background of the December 2020 Dog Attack
The incident occurred on December 12, 2020. Avila went outside to empty a vacuum bag at Brown’s San Fernando Valley residence. Without warning, a massive Caucasian Shepherd named Hades-a guard dog breed often utilized in Russian prisons-pounced on her. Testimony during the trial revealed that the attack caused severe lacerations to her face and arm. This required dozens of stitches and left permanent scarring.
During the trial, Brown testified as the first witness. He recounted hearing the dog growling and rushing downstairs to find Avila motionless and bleeding on the ground. The R&B singer admitted negligence prior to the trial under California’s strict dog-bite statute. However, his defense team continued to dispute the exact extent of Avila’s physical and psychological injuries.
Impact on Ongoing Legal and Financial Obligations
Brown successfully argued that the initial $12.9 million verdict was inflated. Now, the finalization of the $9.5 million figure brings a definitive end to the primary damages dispute. This dispute has stretched across more than five years of litigation. Legal representatives for the R&B star have not yet clarified whether they intend to appeal the newly adjusted figure.
Brown remains active professionally, including touring alongside Usher. Portions of his earnings have previously been earmarked to help satisfy judgments connected to the high-profile civil lawsuit. With the reduction formally accepted, both sides can finally move forward from the long-running courtroom battle.
